With all due respect, it appears the Dorchester Board of Education got this one wrong.
In the six year-plus history of this online publication, we have always supported the tough decisions of our locally elected officials. We vocally supported the school board's decision to build a new school and raise the money to pay for it. We fervently backed the village board's decision to move forward with a plan to clean up neglected properties. And we gave the thumbs up to the school board when they opted to ask Milford Public Schools to allow Dorchester boys to join their football and wrestling teams.
These decisions were made only after months or years of discussion and study. They were demonstrations of sound judgement. They reflected what the vast majority of residents wanted.
This past week, the DPS board, somewhat unexpectedly and in expedited fashion, voted to ask Milford Public Schools allow a two-year co-op arrangement for girls and boys basketball.
DHS is enduring a cycle in which there is a smaller-than-usual number of boys in grades 9-12. While participant numbers will be tight in future years, merging both basketball teams with Milford (or any other school) is unnecessary and unwise. This is not like the situation facing the football program, where DHS students would be without a team if an alternative wasn't offered.
The Dorchester school board should reconsider its latest decision, for several reasons:
1.) School is still about academics. Most of us on the Times staff participated in DHS athletics during our school days. We get it -- athletics provide student athletes valuable lessons and instill pride. They provide a lifetime of memories, even if 99% of our children never play beyond the high school or tiny college stage. That said, it's still just a game. Busing students to Milford unnecessarily (or parents opting to drive 10 or more miles to take their kids to another school) is a tremendously silly drain of time and taxpayer resources. Just plain silly! DHS athletes will find themselves with considerably less time and energy to study and focus on schoolwork -- you know, the reason kids go to school in the first place? To make something of themselves? To be productive members of our society? So that they can get meaningful jobs and earn a decent living?
2.) Sports are still about the kids. Here's a reminder for some of you: It's not about the number of wins and losses; it's about ensuring the maximum number of Dorchester boys and girls who want to play, get to play. Period. If you have five DHS boys who want to play, you field a team. If they don't win a game all season, that's life in a small town -- and the ebb and flow of small school sports. Five years later, your team may be playing in the Pinnacle Arena for the state championship. In the meantime, don't deprive Dorchester kids the opportunity to wear their school colors and to represent the town in which they've been raised. Treat your kids as you would have wanted to be treated when you were their age. And remember: Lifelong lessons are learned even when you don't win all the time.
3.) DPS athletics are still about representing Dorchester. Some of our DPS parents have their loyalties all confused -- saying they prefer Milford, or Friend, or Crete, or Wilber. Well, we prefer Dorchester. And we bet your kids do, too. As we said above, if we can field a basketball team, we should field it here at Dorchester Public School. We should do everything we can to ensure that Dorchester kids who want to play get to wear the orange and black. Communities smaller than Dorchester have united when such issues have arisen; we should not let DHS athletics -- a source of pride for generations -- be a dividing point. Moreover, instead of threatening to enroll our child in another school, we should be teaching him the meaning of loyalty -- to classmates, to school, to hometown. We should be teaching our child to play for something bigger than herself.
Again, this blog urges the Dorchester Board of Education to reconsider its request for an expanded co-op agreement, which would forfeit at least two seasons of DHS boys and girls basketball.
We see little harm in waiting a year to re-evaluate the situation. But we see potential long-term damage if this decision is rushed -- and if Dorchester boys and girls are unnecessarily deprived of the opportunity to wear the orange and black.