In 1880, Dorchester residents went to Pleasant Hill, took apart a church, and hauled it home by wagon.
The building became Dorchester’s Methodist church, one of several houses of worship that took shape in and around the village during its first decades.
Dorchester's Earliest Churches
As Dorchester’s 1981 centennial history book recounts, one of the area’s first congregations had no church building at all. In the early 1870s, German immigrants who settled northeast of town organized an Evangelical congregation in the West Blue area. They worshipped in a log home until 1875, when a small church was built for $450.
In town, the Rev. W.D. Gage came to Dorchester from Nebraska City in the fall of 1872 and held services in the old frame schoolhouse, then the village’s only public building. The first church built within Dorchester’s limits was the Congregational church, erected in 1879. It stood one block north and one block west of today’s post office.
The Methodists got their building the following year, and their minister, the Rev. John Armstrong, was remembered as “a spirited man.” Armstrong was also an attorney, and two local saloonkeepers were among his clients. Some even called Dorchester a “city of rum.”
As Dorchester grew in the 1880s, two United Brethren churches sprang up southwest of town, and another Evangelical church opened to the northwest. By 1884, local Baptists had organized a congregation that went on to build the First Baptist Church of Dorchester.
Remembering the Dunkards
Some worship took place outdoors. The Dunkards apparently had no permanent church building, and The Dorchester Star reported that they baptized converts in Turkey Creek. Dorchester’s Christian congregation also held baptisms in Turkey Creek or the Blue River. When its members built a new church in town in 1908, they installed a baptismal tank behind the altar for full immersion.
Dorchester’s Methodists built a new church in 1904, the same year the West Blue church added a parsonage. The 1904 Methodist church served the community until a new building went up in the 1990s.
By the late 1910s and early 1920s, better roads and automobiles made it easier for families to travel beyond their immediate neighborhoods. Rural congregations found it harder to keep their doors open.
Dorchester Times readers have also pointed us to the former United Missionary Church in the northeast quadrant of Dorchester. The brick building has housed apartments for decades. Readers recall that the Rev. Raymond Butterfield lived in the parsonage next door and that the Rev. Ralph Strom succeeded him as pastor after Butterfield moved to Lincoln.
From the log home at West Blue to the banks of Turkey Creek, Dorchester’s early congregations made places to gather wherever they could. Their churches gave neighbors in town and in the countryside a place to worship and a reason to come together.






















